BBC Culture https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260916-the-secret-life-of-outrageous-us-showman-liberace?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[The secret life of outrageous showman Liberace]]> Thu, 17 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'He wanted to maintain an illusion of agelessness': The secret life of outrageous showman Liberace

Getty Images Liberace in a bubble bath at his home (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

The glitzy pianist, who famously hid his sexuality, was dismissed as a "vulgar joke" in his lifetime. But a new play gets to the truth of who he was, in private as well as in public.

The outlandish pianist and singer Liberace was such an accomplished purveyor of glitzy escapism that he famously called himself a "one-man Disneyland". During his heyday from the 1950s to the 1970s, he was also regularly described as "the world's highest paid entertainer", a claim that is impossible to verify and may well be untrue.

Still, there is no doubt that he liked to project outrageous wealth on stage. When he performed his final live residency, at New York City's Radio City Music Hall in 1985, Liberace made a grand entrance by stepping out of a giant recreation of a Fabergé egg, wearing a cape made of hot pink turkey feathers.

Getty Images Liberace was known for his flamboyant shows in which he played classical and pop tunes alike (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

The man born Władziu Valentino Liberace – but who achieved global fame as a fabulous mononym – died in February 1987 from an Aids-related illness. He had learned around 18 months earlier that he was HIV positive, but never spoke publicly about his diagnosis, just as he always refuted rumours that he was gay. Since his death, however, it has become common knowledge that he enjoyed several long-term relationships with men.

The trial that made Liberace  

Now a new stage play about Liberace, I'll Be Seeing You, which opens this month in Scotland, explores the apparent disconnect between his private and professional lives, as well as the flamboyant piano man's most immaculate deception. In 1959, three years after the Daily Mirror published an article heavily insinuating that he was homosexual, Liberace successfully sued the British newspaper for libel.

The actor who portrays Liberace in the play, revered British Shakespearean Simon Russell Beale, tells the BBC that Liberace made a significant "gamble" by taking the case to court – had he lost, his career could have been ruined. But Beale also observes that the "specific lie that Liberace told" under oath, when he insisted that he was "against the practice [of homosexuality] because it offends convention and it offends society", was "merely part of [his] continuum of lying" – or at least being evasive about – his sexuality. As it transpired, the court ruled in Liberace's favour and awarded him £8,000 in damages – the equivalent to £167,000 ($225,000) today.

I never saw him without his hairpiece, though it did change in colour and style – Bo Ayars

Vincent L Stephens, the author of Rocking the Closet: How Little Richard, Johnnie Ray, Liberace, and Johnny Mathis Queered Pop Music, believes this victory was an emboldening turning point for the nascent showman. "After he won, he gradually became a lot more flamboyant and outgoing in his public persona," Stephens tells the BBC, pointing to the succession of "handsome chauffeurs" that Liberace hired to drive him on stage in his signature Rolls Royce.

One of these, Scott Thorson, sued Liberace for $113 million in palimony in 1982. He claimed that the entertainer had left him penniless after abruptly ending their five-year relationship. Liberace vehemently denied that he was gay and stated in court depositions that Thorson was never his lover. The case was settled in 1986 with Thorson receiving $75,000 in cash as well as three cars and three valuable pet dogs. 

The former driver's 1988 memoir, Behind the Candelabra: My Life with Liberace, was later adapted into an Emmy-winning TV film starring Michael Douglas as Liberace and Matt Damon as Thorson. Conductor and arranger Bo Ayars, who served as Liberace's musical director from 1973 to 1986, tells the BBC that 2013's Behind the Candelabra succeeded in "really showing [Liberace's] idiosyncrasies" as a person and performer.

Getty Images Liberace signing the hand of one of his female fans at London's Royal Festival Hall in 1954 (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Directed with affectionate irreverence by Steven Soderbergh, it doesn't shy away from showing Liberace's determination to maintain a different kind of façade – foregrounding his penchant for cosmetic surgery and showing him undergoing a facelift so extreme that it allegedly left him unable to close his eyelids completely.

Ayars says Liberace believed unwaveringly in "keeping up appearances" as he grew older and increasingly bald. "I never saw him without his hairpiece, though it did change in colour and style," he notes. To Stephens, Liberace's fondness for plastic surgery was entirely "in keeping" with his rigorous approach to image management. "Since his initial appeal was tied to a certain boyish innocence, it seems likely that he wanted to maintain an illusion of agelessness for his audience," he suggests. 

I'll Be Seeing You has enough pedigree to kickstart another revival in interest around Liberace. And in a serendipitous coincidence, it arrives hot on the heels of Liberace & Liza, a musical comedy tribute show in which David Saffert and Jillian Snow play affectionate parodies of Liberace and Liza Minnelli. The cabaret-style romp, which has toured extensively on both sides of the Atlantic while building a healthy following on TikTok, hinges on the irresistible fiction that the two entertainers, who probably never met, were great friends and collaborators.

He understood what his female audience wanted, which was a well-groomed, amusing man who was not unlike an unthreatening brother – Simon Russell Beale

"As I looked into his career, I started to realise that he was rarely given enough credit as a musician," Saffert tells the BBC. I'll Be Seeing You star Beale says he is especially interested in "how we regard Liberace" as a cultural figure because he was often dismissed as a "vulgar joke" in his lifetime. "I think there's a huge amount of snobbery surrounding him," Beale adds. "Nobody ever mentions that he must have worked at being such an extraordinary piano player." 

His journey to the top of showbiz

In fact, Liberace worked incredibly hard from the start. Born in May 1919 to parents with Italian and Polish roots, he grew up in a working-class household in Wisconsin where his father, Salvatore, did manual labour in addition to playing the French horn in local bands. His mother, Frances, had been a concert pianist before she was married, but it was Salvatore who determined that the young Władziu – or Walter, to friends – should begin piano lessons at just four years old. 

At 13, he started playing professionally at weddings, dance classes and even strip clubs to supplement the family's income during the Great Depression. Still, despite the odd insalubrious gig, the prodigiously gifted Liberace seemed destined to become a serious classical musician. On 15 January 1940, around six months before his 21st birthday, he made his debut with the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, billed as the soloist during a performance of Liszt's Piano Concerto No 2.

Alamy Michael Douglas as Liberace and Matt Damon as his lover Scott Thorson in 2013 biopic Behind the Candelabra (Credit: Alamy)Alamy

However, by this point, Liberace's head was already being turned by the power of popular music. As he perfected his act at nightclubs and hotel lounges throughout the 1940s, Liberace began to blend classical compositions with seemingly incongruous contemporary songs like the sentimental folk ballad Home on the Range and energetic jazz standard Tiger Rag. Reflecting on his decision to eschew a career as a traditional concert pianist, Liberace told TV interviewer Michael Parkinson in 1973: "I love classical music, but I think I would have been a much lonelier person if I'd been a strictly classical pianist, because you play to a different audience of people." The audience he targeted with gusto, Liberace added shrewdly, were "truly the working-class people" who would "really let go" at his shows.

In the 1950s, Liberace found the ideal medium to cultivate this mainstream fanbase when his weekly TV series, The Liberace Show, became a ratings sensation in the US and UK. Remarkably, his popularity flourished in the face of thinly veiled homophobia from TV critics, who made what Stephens describes as "veiled comments about him not being a 'regular' or 'traditional' guy". However, Liberace's core demographic of mainly middle-aged and older women "rallied behind him" and remained loyal until his death in 1987, ensuring he remained an enormous live draw long after The Liberace Show ended in 1959. 

From this point on, Liberace maintained his profile with witty guest spots on TV chat shows and honed his showy yet homely persona right down to his signature stage prop, a candelabra perched on the piano, which struck the right note of aspirational suburban glamour. "He understood what his female audience wanted, which was a well-groomed, amusing man who was not unlike an unthreatening brother or [platonic] companion," Beale says. 

More like this:

In 2026, when gay people enjoy greater visibility than Liberace could have imagined in his lifetime, it would be easy to perceive him as the archetypal "tragic homosexual" – how could he be happy when he hid a huge part of himself? However, this reductive view fails to factor in his sizable appetite for life. "All his friends seemed to like him and he was never accused of lacking generosity, so I think he was probably quite a simple man with simple desires," Beale suggests. "If he'd said, 'yes, I'm gay' [on record], he would have lost his career, so he chose not to. What's complex about that?"

Ayars roundly agrees with this assessment: "He always seemed genuinely happy and would laugh off comments about his private life". He believes the real Liberace was a performer of rare stamina – they racked up around 5,000 shows together, often performing twice a night – who loved to dazzle audiences while accruing the glamorous trappings of success. "His piano technique was great, though I never saw him practise," Ayars says, "but in terms of showmanship and entertaining people, he really was a king." 

I'll be Seeing You is at Scotland's Pitlochry Theatre from September 22 until October 11. 

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260915-why-mary-magdalene-is-a-divisive-biblical-figure?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[Why Mary Magdalene is a divisive biblical figure]]> Wed, 16 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

Penitent sinner or fiery saint? Mary Magdalene is one of the Bible's most divisive figures. These paintings show why

Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection The painting La sfida (The Challenge) which shows Magdalene wearing a red dress with long auburn hair (Credit: Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection)Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection

Known as the "apostle to the apostles”, the controversial and multifaceted saint Mary Magdalene is shrouded in mythology and mystery. What do these artworks reveal about her?

Few biblical figures have fascinated society more than Mary Magdalene, said to be the first person to witness Christ's resurrection and to share the news. For centuries, Magdalene, a follower of Jesus known as the "apostle to the apostles", has maintained a passionate following among religious and secular communities alike, despite the Bible containing relatively few references to her. As a result, the mythology surrounding her has eclipsed who she actually was.

Over time, Magdalene's name has come to represent an amalgamation of different biblical characters and historical ideas, some of which have become more strongly associated with her than the biblical accounts themselves. This is what Mary Magdalene. Sin. Pray. Love., an exhibition opening at the Städel Museum in Frankfurt explores.

"We essentially discovered that there are three Mary Magdalenes in one," says art historian Bastian Eclercy, who has co-curated the exhibition. "One is the nameless sinner, the other one is Mary of Bethany and the third is the biblical Mary Magdalene in the strict sense."

And as its title suggests, the exhibition looks at three key ways Magdalene has been represented. "'Sin' stands for the image of the sinner and penitent that has shaped perceptions over the centuries; 'Pray' for Mary Magdalene as a saint and disciple of Jesus; and 'Love' for the various notions of love, devotion and intimacy associated with her," Eclercy tells the BBC.

Here, we look at 10 works from the exhibition that illustrate the different views on Magdalene – and changing perceptions of women over time. 

Städel Museum, Frankfurt (Credit: Städel Museum, Frankfurt)Städel Museum, Frankfurt

The Elevation of Saint Mary Magdalene by Albrecht Dürer (c 1504-05)

In German artist Albrecht Dürer's woodcut print on paper, a nude Magdalene is lifted towards the sky by six angels. The scene is inspired by The Golden Legend, a 13th-Century text by the Italian chronicler and archbishop Jacobus de Voragine. In one of the popular stories included in the legend, Mary retreats to the South of France in search of solitude. "There was no food available in the wilderness, and so seven times a day, she was taken up by angels and elevated into heaven to listen to their music, and that was her food," Eclercy says.

The National Gallery, London (Credit: The National Gallery, London)The National Gallery, London

Mary Magdalene at the Tomb by Giovanni Girolamo Savoldo (c 1535-40)

While the Italian oil painting isn't immediately recognisable as Magdalene, for experts, the small vase in the left-hand corner and red dress (broadly associated with sensuality and danger) peeking out from underneath a silver satin cloak has helped to identify her.

"Some people have argued that it could be Mary the Mother [of Christ] because we don't have many obvious tropes, but I think it is Mary Magdalene because we've got that white alabaster jar in it," says Siobhan Jolley, lecturer in Christian studies at the University of Manchester in the UK, who is curating a National Gallery touring exhibition on Mary Magdalene, set to open in 2027. She notes that the jar is associated with the unnamed female "sinner" in the Bible who anointed Jesus's feet.

Artworks through the centuries that depict Magdalene do not, in Jolley's view, tell us much about her as an actual individual. "They tell us, to my mind at least, a lot more about what different cultures have wanted women to be," she says.

Uffizi, Florence (Credit: Uffizi, Florence)Uffizi, Florence

Christ appears to Mary Magdalene by Lavinia Fontana (1581)

Italian Mannerist painter Lavinia Fontana paints Magdalene in her signature red dress. It is one of the few early depictions of the saint by a woman artist. "While you might be looking for a kind of female gaze, this is something that we could not detect," says Eclercy. Fontana directly references a biblical scene where Mary mistakes Jesus for a gardener. In the painting, he is dressed as a traditional 16th-Century Italian labourer in a wide-brimmed hat and tunic.

 

Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna (Credit: Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna)Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna

Martha Rebuking her Vain Sister Mary Magdalene by Simon Vouet (1621)

Many historical and contemporary ideas of Magdalene conflate different figures in the Bible, including an unnamed "sinful woman" who anointed Jesus's feet, an adulterer, and Mary of Bethany, the relative of two other biblical figures, Martha and Lazarus. "This is what [art historian] Marina Warner calls 'the muddle of Marys' – where artists are not separating between different Marys as long as [the figure] does whatever job she needs to do in the painting or the story to make a point," Jolley says. In Vouet's painting, Magdalene is in a made-up scene (not in the Bible) at a dressing table and is being reprimanded by her sister Martha for being too vain. 

Bibliotheca Hertziana, Istituto Max Planck/ Enrico Fontolan (Credit: Bibliotheca Hertziana, Istituto Max Planck/ Enrico Fontolan)Bibliotheca Hertziana, Istituto Max Planck/ Enrico Fontolan

Penitent Magdalene by Guido Cagnacci (1626-27)

Magdalene in a state of contrition is a popular trope in art history. "She has become a role model for penitents, both male and female," says Eclercy. Western traditions in particular have progressively associated Magdalene with sexual sin, something that becomes clear in many paintings such as Cagnacci's, where themes of sexual desire are inescapable. 

While there is no direct scripture stating the wrongdoing of the unnamed "sinful woman", many have presumed it to be sexual. "It's really common to hear her described as a sex worker particularly in older texts, though we don't have any real foundation for that in biblical documents," Jolley says. "For artists, it's an opportunity to be a bit racy with a holy image. They know they can get away with depicting her as alluring or slightly sexualised in a way that they can't with other saints." In Cagnacci's painting, Magdalene holds a skull, often used in art history as a reminder that life is short and that we should prepare our souls to meet God. 

National Gallery of Art, Washington (Credit: National Gallery of Art, Washington)National Gallery of Art, Washington

Penitent Magdalene in Meditation by Georges de la Tour (1635-40)

Georges de La Tour's version of a "penitent Magdalene" is notably gentler. "I like that La Tour gives us a kind of interior Magdalene," says Jolley. "We've got mirrors, candles, and other tropes of time, mortality and self-reflection without the artist needing to make [the painting] appealing in some other way." His paintings could be said to reject traditional portrayals of women in art as decorative or erotic. 

Kunstmuseum Basel, Basel (Credit: Kunstmuseum Basel, Basel)Kunstmuseum Basel, Basel

Magdalene Grieving over the Body of Christ by Arnold Böcklin (1867)

The Swiss painter portrays a dramatic Magdalene standing by Jesus's lifeless body. Instead of conforming to traditional portrayals of Magdalene as subdued or overtly sexual, Böcklin creates this fiery character, permitted to express the full range of her emotions, and thus mourn Jesus intensely. "Mary Magdalene is taking on the role of the Virgin Mary in a way," says Eclercy. "Expressing the utmost grief that you can have."

Saint Louis Art Museum/ Bequest of Curt Valentin (Credit: Saint Louis Art Museum/ Bequest of Curt Valentin)Saint Louis Art Museum/ Bequest of Curt Valentin

Christ and the Sinner by Max Beckmann (1917)

Interchangeably titled Christ and the Sinner, or Christ and the Woman Taken in Adultery, this painting is said to portray a famous biblical scene of Jesus stopping an angry mob from stoning an unnamed woman to death (a story that has become associated with Magdalene over time). In earlier works, where Magdalene is overly sexualised, "it tells us more about what people are imagining the worst thing a woman could be," Jolley says. Instead, Beckmann offers a more forgiving interpretation of this narrative. 

 

Noordbrabants Museum/ JK Art Collection/ Marlene Dumas (Credit: Noordbrabants Museum/ JK Art Collection/ Marlene Dumas)Noordbrabants Museum/ JK Art Collection/ Marlene Dumas

Naomi Campbell as Maria Magdalena by Marlene Dumas (1996)

The South African artist's representation of Magdalene as Naomi Campbell addresses several ideas at once. Not only does it "say something about celebrity and reputation, which is what Mary Magdalene has endured throughout time," says Jolley, "it asks us to think about how we racialise beauty." While there is very little description in the Bible of Magdalene's physical appearance, in Western art, the saint is often portrayed as young and white. Dumas offers us something else to consider.

 "The work feels like a mirror for the audience... back on to society," Jolley adds, noting that people often feel like they know her despite understanding very little about her. "People have a parasocial relationship with Mary Magdalene. They have a sense of her that they encounter with popular culture and in art that isn't really underpinned by knowledge of the biblical character – or any real interest in that." 

Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection (Credit: Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection)Nieves González/ on loan from a private collection

La sfida (The Challenge) by Nieves González (2025)

Spanish visual artist Nieves González manages to keep many of Magdalene's trademarks – her auburn-blonde hair, red clothing, and her holding a skull – while modernising the famous figure by placing her in an oversized puffer jacket. Eclercy believes González is "presenting this extremely self-confident young woman." Magdalene's stare at the viewer is unapologetic. "This is a work about agency and ownership," Jolley adds. "You almost get a sense that she's kind of asking you, 'What do you want to say about me?'"

Mary Magdalene: Sin. Pray. Love. is at the Städel Museum, Frankfurt from 17 September to 17 January 2027.

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260914-the-unsolved-mystery-of-lizzie-borden-and-the-grisly-fall-river-axe-murders?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[The unsolved mystery of the Fall River axe murders]]> Tue, 15 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'A story of deep psychological drama': The notorious axe murders of Lizzie Borden's parents still haunt, 134 years on

Alamy A close up portrait of Lizzie Borden (Credit: Alamy)Alamy

In June 1893, Lizzie Borden was tried and acquitted of the murder of her father and stepmother. It became one of the most infamous unsolved mysteries in US history – and the subject of novels, films and a new Netflix drama.

By vividly dramatising the lives of notorious killers, creators Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan have turned Monster, their true-crime anthology show on Netflix, into a smash hit. Serial slayer Jeffery Dahmer, patricidal brothers Lyle and Erik Menendez, and Wisconsin murderer-cum-grave-robber Ed Gein have all received the "Monster" treatment – portrayals that Murphy says aim to address one question: Are monsters made or are they born?

Warning: This article contains details that some readers may find upsetting.

For the fourth season, the duo has selected Lizzie Borden as the focus of their creative speculation. And they are hardly the first. For decades, novelists, dramatists, poets – even opera composers and rock musicians – have been inspired by the macabre story of the American woman who was accused of two grisly murders in August 1892. 

It is so infamous in the history of crime in the US that schoolchildren still recite the ditty: "Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother 40 whacks / And when she saw what she had done, she gave her father 41."

A harrowing crime 

While the rhyme might misidentify the killer, it also exaggerates the number of blows as well as the weapon (it was a hatchet, a small axe that is light enough to use with one hand). But the sequence of events is accurate – whoever killed Andrew and Abby Borden on a hot summer morning in Fall River, Massachusetts, began with Abby. She was 64, Andrew's second wife, and stepmother to his two unmarried daughters Emma, 41, and Lizzie, 32.

More than an hour later, when Andrew came home from running errands, he too met his end. Summoned by Lizzie, the police found her father on the living room sofa, nearly unrecognisable, after 11 hatchet blows.

Alamy Although Lizzie Borden was tried and acquitted of the murders in June 1893, she lived under a cloud of suspicion (Credit: Alamy)Alamy

Such was the brutality of the crime, authorities at first did not suspect Lizzie, a seemingly mild woman who taught at Fall River's Central Congregational Church. Yet at the inquest, she kept changing her account of her movements on the morning of the murders, when only she and Bridget Sullivan, the family's Irish maid, were at the house. (Emma was away on holiday and a house guest had gone out.)

Besides, although Lizzie and her sister denied it, friends and neighbours were aware of tensions in the home. Andrew was a wealthy but miserly man who forced his daughters to live in a shabby part of town and scrimp on household expenses, while he gave money to his new wife's family.

If we are saying that Lizzie Borden is the killer, then this is really a story of deep psychological drama – Cara Robertson

After a local pharmacist reported that Lizzie had tried to buy poisonous prussic acid on the day before the murders, a judge had her arrested and jailed. Then, in December, a friend testified to a grand jury that Lizzie had burned a dress (supposedly her own) in the stove a few days after the killings. Formal charges of murder were brought, and a trial date set for the following June.

In his book Lizzie Borden on Trial: Murder, Ethnicity and Gender, historian and Fall River native Joseph Conforti recounts how Lizzie, with her late father's money, hired a top lawyer from Boston to defend her in front of the all-male jury. (Only men could serve on juries in that era.) "She presented herself as a helpless maiden," Conforti wrote. "Her lawyers told her to dress in black. She appeared in court tightly corseted, dressed in flowing clothes, and holding a bouquet of flowers in one hand and a fan in the other."

An unsolved mystery with a cultural impact

Because the murder weapon was never found, and the suspicious pharmacy visit ruled inadmissible, the case against Borden remained circumstantial. Convinced that Lizzie possessed neither the physical strength nor the moral depravity to be what the prosecution called a "feral… insane fiend", the jury acquitted her after a brief deliberation.

But no one else was ever tried for the gruesome killings, and Lizzie lived under a cloud of suspicion, shunned by many in her hometown, for the remainder of her life.

So why does the Lizzie Borden story continue to be so fascinating – especially to writers?

"There's something about an acquittal that's open-ended," Cara Robertson, author of The Trial of Lizzie Borden, tells the BBC. "And the case has a lot of what we look for in a detective story: limited number of suspects, it hinges on alibis of timing, and if we are saying that Lizzie Borden is the killer, then this is really a story of deep psychological drama."

Fiction writers have explored Borden and her circle in dozens of novels, stories, and retellings. Angela Carter's spookily claustrophobic short story from 1982, The Fall River Axe Murders, reimagines the hours leading up to the murders. "Every image reminds you that Lizzie's world is overheated, literally stinking, and emotionally stultifying," wrote Celeste Ng, author of Little Fires Everywhere, in Fiction Writer's Review. "We never see the hatchet fall. We don't need to."

Getty Images Elizabeth Montgomery earned an Emmy nomination for her portrayal of Lizzie Borden in 1975 (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Three notable filmed versions of the killings have been produced over the last half century, starting in 1975 with The Legend of Lizzie Borden, a critically acclaimed ABC television film. Elizabeth Montgomery of Bewitched fame earned an Emmy nomination for her portrayal of Lizzie.

Here, the suspect is an aloof, steely-eyed Victorian lady, someone who gives nothing away, let alone a confession of murder. While the question of guilt is never directly addressed, Montgomery as Borden wields a hatchet in speculative, dreamlike flashbacks. 

Christina Ricci was cast as the accused murderer for the 2014 Lifetime TV movie Lizzie Borden Took an Ax. Ricci played Lizzie as a recognisably modern type: the malevolent, scheming, high-school mean girl. According to a review in the Hollywood Reporter, Ricci "relishes every moment of her portrayal, turning up the volume on her crazy eyes without spilling over into camp". Lifetime followed up the next year with an eight-episode mini-series The Lizzie Borden Chronicles.

Lizzie, a 2018 psychological thriller with Chloe Sevigny in the title role, is a feminist-coded retelling. Borden is the oppressed daughter driven to murder, spurred on by her love for the maid, Bridget Sullivan (Kristen Stewart), whom Andrew has sexually assaulted. (A romance between Borden and Sullivan was also imagined in Evan Hunter's 1984 novel, Lizzie). Sevigny researched the case as a passion project for nearly a decade before producing as well as starring in the film. For her, Borden was "like an American outlaw who fights against the patriarchy".

A new dramatisation

Viewers of Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story can expect something closer to Sevigny's portrayal than Ricci's. The newest Lizzie, Ella Beatty (daughter of Warren Beatty and Annette Benning) has said that the show explores "a legacy of female rage and reaction to the set of circumstances that they are presented with".

Netflix Ella Beatty stars as Lizzie Borden in a new Netflix drama by creators Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan (Credit: Netflix)Netflix

In a recent interview Ryan said he enjoyed investigating the Borden case because "in many ways you can look at what it deals with [in terms of] women and society and it's very much about today".

The Monster trailer hints that once again Lizzie will be shown caught up in an intimate relationship with Bridget Sullivan. Robertson, who has spent more than 30 years studying and writing about the Borden case, tells the BBC she isn't surprised – many novelists and film-makers have "found the story as is kind of inadequate… for a long time they would simply invent a male love interest. More recently they found someone in the house, namely the maid."

But this choice, Robertson points out, is undermined by some known facts about Borden's treatment of Sullivan. "I suppose [a romance] is possible, but it's also true that Lizzie never bothered to call her by her real name." Instead, Lizzie called Sullivan Maggie, the name of a previous maid.

More like this: 

One curious twist in this season of Monster is the weaving in of a second story, that of a more contemporary murderer. Some scenes will feature Sarah Paulson playing Aileen Wuornos, a sex worker in Florida convicted in 1992 of killing seven of her male clients. By linking the two cases, the Monster makers seem to be making a larger point: while women are far less likely to kill than men, in certain circumstances their rage can turn murderous. 

Borden herself isn't known to have behaved violently before or after the case, so what could have motivated her to pick up a hatchet with lethal intent – if indeed she did? Given that we'll never have the answer, Monster's new "take" on her won't be the last word on the subject.

Other imaginative minds will revisit the events of August 1892, probing a brutal crime that remains confounding.

Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is released on 17 September on Netflix.

-- 

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.  

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram. 

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260911-the-tomb-raiders-who-plundered-million-dollar-pots?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[The tomb raiders who plundered million-dollar pots]]> Mon, 14 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'This is a story about buried treasure': The 1970s tomb raiders who plundered 'million-dollar pots'

Getty Images A black-and-white photo of a group of people looking at a classic Roman pot behind glass (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

It was one of the finest pieces of art ever bought by the Met. But it had been excavated by an Italian grave robber, then smuggled to the US. In 1975, the BBC investigated the lucrative global trade in stolen antiquities.

In September 1972, New York's Metropolitan Museum of Art (the Met) purchased an ancient Greek vase for $1.2m ($9.6m or £7.1m today). Created around 515BC and signed by the painter Euphronios, it is considered one of the best surviving examples of ancient Greek pottery. "From this moment, histories of art will have to be rewritten," boasted the Met's director after the sale was announced, claiming that the vase was one of the two or three finest works of art ever owned by the museum.

But there were soon accusations that the vase had been illegally excavated and smuggled into the US, giving it the nickname "the hot pot". A BBC reporter, John Percival, followed its trail to the underground tombs of a necropolis just outside Cerveteri, Italy, where a professional grave robber, or tombarolo, was said to have unearthed it. And the excitement generated by its price meant that there was renewed activity in the area. "The Italian robbers are chasing million-dollar pots," said Percival. "The Italian cops are chasing the robbers."

Speaking on the BBC's Treasure Trail in 1975, Percival summed up the situation: "This is a story about buried treasure, about gold, silver and precious things hidden in the Earth long ago. It's about the thieves who dig for it by night, about the dealers who smuggle it across frontiers, about the collectors and the great museums that act as receivers of stolen goods."

"The destruction starts at the place where the object is found," Dr Nusin Askari, an expert at the Istanbul Museum, told the BBC. "It's broken so that it can be sold for a higher price in the end and so that it can be transported and smuggled out of the country easier."

To try and control the stolen antiquities trade in the Cerveteri area, a special team of police was trained in ancient art, attending lectures by an expert at Rome's Villa Giulia Museum. Yet illegal excavations were difficult to patrol, and kept appearing like giant potholes dotted around Italian fields. 

"The whole area is littered with absolutely hundreds of tombs which can be opened up easily," said Percival, crouching next to a freshly dug pit that had appeared that morning. It was an early Etruscan tomb, with grave goods not as rich as those found in some later ones, and the robbers had left behind multiple fragments not worth removing.

Buying artefacts, no questions asked 

In a nearby area also plundered by grave robbers, Etruscan pots recovered from illegal excavations were piled in a museum courtyard. Next to them was a stack of long metal skewers or kiavi, which the robbers used to probe the ground, looking for hollow places in the soft bedrock.

Yet some tomb raiders had more sophisticated kit. "Nowadays, there's some very fine electronic equipment that's available, and these people do use this," the US explorer Howard Jennings told the BBC, describing the activities of treasure hunters in South America at the time. "It eliminates an awful lot of digging if you can locate metal objects, and it's metal objects that these people are generally after because gold is more easily smuggled out than bulky pottery."

He explained how the value of the loot was determined in a straightforward way. "The wholesale price of pre-Columbian gold artefacts is around 15 times its weight in gold. So if the curator of a museum agrees to purchase, the gold objects are simply weighed, and a bit of multiplication is done on the basis of 15 times that weight, and that's how the payment's made."

While laws have since been tightened, there was almost a Wild West feel to the situation Jennings described in 1975. "There are vast areas of South America, particularly in Ecuador, that are totally unexplored and unmapped, and it's very easy for a person to simply disappear into a jungle for months on end in areas where there are literally hundreds of burial mounds," he said. "They can work there without any question of the authorities finding them. And they stay until they've acquired all that they feel that they can smuggle out of the country – and then out they come and away they go."

In History

In History is a series which uses the BBC's unique audio and video archive to explore historical events that still resonate today. Sign up to the accompanying weekly newsletter.

Disposing of smuggled antiquities was easy, according to Jennings. "They're in great demand. The only thing the museums, the auction houses, the dealers, private collectors want to know is, is this artefact authentic? Once that's been determined, that it's an authentic antiquity, there are no other questions asked."

Yet countries rich in archaeological sites have passed laws forbidding the export of antiquities. Illegal shipments are regularly intercepted by the authorities, and many stolen artefacts have been returned to their countries of origin. The Met's "hot pot" was sent back to Italy in 2008, after it was found to have passed through the hands of antiquities smuggler Giacomo Medici, convicted of trafficking in looted objects in 2005. "But as long as there's a market," said Percival, "the pillage of the past goes on." 

More like this:

"From murderous temple thieves in India to church pillagers in Bolivia to hundred-man bands of tomb raiders in China's Liaoning Province, looters are strip-mining our past," said a 2016 National Geographic article, arguing that "satellite imagery, police seizures, and witness reports from the field all indicate that the trade in stolen treasures is booming around the world". 

All that plundering damages our understanding of our history. "It matters because it's destroying knowledge," museum curator Nick Thomas told the BBC. Looting any archaeological site, "whether it's a grand temple or a minor tomb with just two or three pots and a skeleton… is simply destroying knowledge about our past which we can pass on to the future."

--

For more stories and never-before-published radio scripts to your inbox, sign up to the In History newsletter, while The Essential List delivers a handpicked selection of features and insights twice a week.  

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram. 

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260911-six-of-the-best-oscar-contenders-from-the-2026-venice-film-festival?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[Six Oscar contenders from the Venice Film Festival]]> Sat, 12 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

Primetime to Flesh Impact: Six of the best Oscar contenders from the 2026 Venice film festival

Venice Film Festival A close up of Dakota Johnson as Marilyn Monroe (Credit: Venice Film Festival)Venice Film Festival

From a wild-eyed performance by Robert Pattinson to an Elon Musk documentary and a short film about Marilyn Monroe at 100, here are the Venice films attracting Oscars buzz.

The Venice International Film Festival is often a launchpad for films that rocket their way to Oscar glory. Over the past decade, these have included La La Land and The Shape of Water, Roma and The Brutalist, Joker and Frankenstein. This year's festival featured fewer big-budget Hollywood awards contenders than usual, but here are six films that are already fizzing with Oscar buzz.

A24 (Credit: A24)A24

Primetime

Robert Pattinson has had quite a year. He was hilariously flustered in The Drama and scene-stealingly oily in The Odyssey, and now he excels in the juiciest role of his career. Primetime tells the story of Chris Hansen and his controversial television show, To Catch a Predator, which tricked potential sex offenders into incriminating themselves on camera in the early 2000s. Pattinson, who also produces the film, is in almost every scene. He moves and sounds just like the real Hansen, while adding some signature touches of reptilian menace and wild-eyed obsession. Between the Academy's taste for impersonations of real people, and Pattinson's popularity as an art-house character actor with Hollywood leading-man charisma, it could be time for his first Oscar nomination.

Searchlight Pictures (Credit: Searchlight Pictures)Searchlight Pictures

Wild Horse Nine

Martin McDonagh's last film, The Banshees of Inisherin, was nominated for nine Oscars, but didn't win any. Could Wild Horse Nine do any better? A politically charged black comedy about two CIA agents on holiday on Easter Island in 1973, it's a showcase for another of McDonagh's dysfunctional double acts, but instead of Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson, who starred together in The Banshees of Inisherin and In Bruges, the two main men are played by John Malkovich and Sam Rockwell. Malkovich is a best actor front-runner. He is always magnetically weird, but here, as a pained, red-eyed, ageing assassin, he is touching and complex too. It helps that the 72-year-old has been nominated for two previous Oscars, most recently for In the Line of Fire (1993), and that Academy voters love a "comeback" narrative.

Venice Film Festival (Credit: Venice Film Festival)Venice Film Festival

Flesh Impact

Flesh Impact is a Venice rarity: a potential Oscar nominee in the best live action short film category. A warm-hearted 17-minute charmer, it was written and directed by Maggie Gyllenhaal and commissioned to celebrate Marilyn Monroe's centenary. Gyllenhaal imagines Monroe as a sprightly 100-year-old auditioning for a Broadway play (Gyllenhaal's husband, Peter Sarsgaard, plays the director), and taking the opportunity to tell her life story in her own words. "Flesh impact," she explains, was Billy Wilder's term for the quality that made cinema viewers believe they could reach out and touch her. In a stroke of casting genius, Monroe is played by the 93-year-old Ellen Burstyn (an Oscar, Emmy and Tony winner), while Dakota Johnson plays her younger self in flashback.

Andrejs Strokins (Credit: Andrejs Strokins)Andrejs Strokins

Woman Unknown

As soon as Woman Unknown premiered, this steely Danish drama was mentioned as a potential best international film nominee, thanks to its heavyweight themes, nerve-racking plot, impeccable period details, and its terrifically contained but expressive performance by Mathilde Arkel. Directed by May el-Toukhy (it was the only film in Venice's main competition strand to be directed by a woman), Woman Unknown is set in Copenhagen just after World War Two. Arkel plays a nanny who is now engaged to her boss, a widowed industrialist (Carsten Bjornlund). But one day on the tram, an old schoolmate recognises her, and threatens to expose the sexual relationship she had with a German during the Nazi occupation. Woman Unknown examines the lines people will cross to survive, and the way men justify their abuse of women.

Netflix (Credit: Netflix)Netflix

Possible Love

Lee Chang-dong's last film, Burning, came out in 2018, but the intricacy and delicacy of his follow-up, Possible Love, suggests why it might have taken so long. This piquant drama revolves around a middle-class director (Cho Yeo-jeong) who, with the help of her wealthy husband (Zo In-sung), is making a documentary about a striking factory worker (Sul Kyung-gu) and his wife (Jeon Do-yeon). She bonds with her subjects over drunken dinners and weekend breaks. But can the two couples have a genuine connection across the class divide, or is theirs is a friendship of convenience? Possible Love currently has a 100% score on the Rotten Tomatoes reviews round-up site, so it's more than possible that it will be nominated for a best international film Oscar.

Getty Images (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Musk

Alex Gibney's profile of Elon Musk, the richest man in the world, is a four-hour epic. Without pausing for breath, the documentary races through the tech mogul's life, from his childhood in South Africa to his years as a geeky Silicon Valley hopeful, to his trillion-dollar success as the boss of Tesla and SpaceX, to his support of far-right political parties around the world. Gibney's Taxi to the Dark Side won the Academy Award for best documentary in 2008, and Musk is making so many headlines that it could do the same. The tycoon himself called it "a hit piece that misses and makes the fatal sin of being boring for four hours". He couldn't be more wrong.

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260910-the-extraordinary-story-of-barbara-cartland-the-forgotten-billions-selling-romance-author?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[The extraordinary story of author Barbara Cartland]]> Fri, 11 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'Main character energy': The extraordinary story of Barbara Cartland, the forgotten millions-selling romance author

Getty Images Barbara wears an all pink outfit and smiles at the camera while stood in front of a white car (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Although Barbara Cartland sold around 750 million books, you'll struggle to find a copy in a bookshop today. And the socialite led an extraordinary and surprising life - why has the UK's master of romantic fiction disappeared from memory?

To take your place behind William Shakespeare and Agatha Christie as the third best-selling author in history is a remarkable feat. Yet, ask most people what they know of the late romantic novelist Dame Barbara Cartland and it's probably not her literary success that they'll mention.

Instead, people might recall her penchant for pink, particularly her uniform of billowing, candy-coloured gowns. Or her famously thick, sooty eyelashes (created not with mascara, but boot polish applied with a toothbrush). They might remember that she always had a small dog tucked under her arm, that she reportedly took 90 vitamin pills a day and that she had a famous spat with Jackie Collins on live TV, calling her books "evil". Or that she was the step-grandmother of the late Princess Diana – who loved her books.

It would be good if she was remembered as something more than a joke… she achieved something that ought to be acknowledged in some way – Matthew Sweet

Even those who remember a time when Cartland's books were ubiquitous on UK supermarket shelves will likely struggle to recall the titles. Cartland wrote a staggering 723 books in her lifetime – mostly historical romances featuring innocent young heroines trying to tame dashing but troubled dukes, lords and captains.

But a quarter-of-a-century on from her death it is the woman, rather than what she produced on the page, whose presence still lingers.

Getty Images Outsold only by Shakespeare and Agatha Christie, Barbara Cartland's eccentric image has overshadowed her novels (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Much of this is down to Cartland herself, a master of personal branding long before social media made it commonplace, who carefully created and controlled her image. When quarantine restrictions meant she couldn't take her dogs on a US publicity tour, she appeared with a stuffed Pekingese under her arm so as not to shatter the illusion.

Cartland issued journalists with indemnity forms and demanded copy approval on interviews. She had three authorised biographers in her lifetime, resulting in two gushing hagiographies and one more balanced account, from which Cartland – on seeing the manuscript – promptly withdrew her approval and fast-tracked a sanitised memoir of her own to try and divert attention.

A new biography of Cartland out this week would no doubt horrify the woman herself. It goes beyond the perfectly coiffed image to examine properly her extraordinary career and equally remarkable life. "There are all of these things you can say about Barbara Cartland, like she's the third best-selling author of all time, that don't match up with the cultural memory of her," says Matthew Sweet, author of The Great Dictator: A Life of Barbara Cartland (the title refers to the fact that Cartland didn't type her books, but dictated them to a secretary from her chaise longue). 

"It would be good if she was remembered as something more than a joke. That's not to say she wasn't funny and absurd because she was, but she achieved something that ought to be acknowledged in some way. If you dismiss her, you're also dismissing all her readers too, and there were two post-war generations to whom she was very important."

Getty Images A new biography is titled The Great Dictator, referring to the fact that Cartland dictated her novels to a secretary (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Cartland's granddaughter Tara McCorquodale gave Matthew Sweet full access to her archives at Camfield Place, the country home where the writer lived from the 1950s until her death. "I had free rein of the whole house and all the papers in it, some of which had not been touched for a quarter-of-a-century," says Sweet.

The result is a book that, while gloriously entertaining and packed with plenty of jaw-dropping anecdotes about Cartland's behaviour, also places the writer in the context of an era of huge political and social change.

A 20th-Century woman

Cartland's life spanned almost the entirety of the 20th Century. Born in 1901, she lived through two world wars, the sexual revolution of the 1960s, the women's liberation movement, the UK's first female prime minister and the birth of the internet. She launched her own website a few months before her death in 2000.

Sweet argues that the inciting incident in Cartland's life happened when she was barely two years old and her paternal grandfather killed himself after going bankrupt. His death marked a change in the family's fortunes, with Barbara's parents leaving their grand Worcestershire home for a much more modest life. While her father turned to alcohol, Cartland's mother Polly tried desperately to cling on to their place in high society. As a young woman, this would also preoccupy Barbara who, despite a lack of funds, found herself mixing with the Bright Young Things of the era.

"She didn't have lots of resources to draw from, and so she always had to make the best of herself and just go for everything in this demonically energetic way," says Sweet.

Cartland started her career as a newspaper gossip columnist, before publishing her first novel Jigsaw in 1925, a tale of a young woman who leaves her French convent school and heads to London in search of love.

Getty Images As a young woman, Barbara mixed with the Bright Young Things of the era (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Her own love life gave her plenty of inspiration to draw from. She fielded 49 marriage proposals before accepting what turned out to be the wrong one. After divorcing her first husband for adultery she then married his cousin, handily keeping the same married name, McCorquodale.

Unlike the historical romances that she later became famous for, her earlier books had contemporary settings. "Some of her early work, particularly her writing in the 1920s and '30s was quite groundbreaking," says Dr Amy Burge, associate professor in Popular Fiction at the University of Birmingham and co-author of The Bonkbuster: Women's Popular Reading in the Long 1980s.

The joy of a romance novel is that you know it's going to end happily. The anticipation and the pleasure is in how you get there – Amy Burge

A 1926 play, Blood Money, was initially banned for being too racy. Her 1935 novel First Class Lady featured a character who has an illegal abortion, causing its censorship in Ireland. And 1936's Dangerous Experiment was one of only a handful British novels of the time to address the rise of Nazi antisemitism. 

'I give them glamour' 

Cartland's imperial phase came during the golden age of cheap mass market paperbacks in the 1960s, '70s and '80s. Publishers were hungry for manuscripts, and Barbara was happy to oblige, producing books at the alarming speed of one a fortnight. "The one author in the world with 150 virgins lying about was me," she said. 

By this point her novels were set in the past, mainly the 19th Century. They were formulaic, but that was part of the appeal. "Repetition is comforting," says Burge. "The joy of a romance novel is that you know it's going to end happily. The anticipation and the pleasure is in how you get there." 

While her fictional worlds often involved high society, Cartland's readers were largely working-class women. "I'm selling millions of paperbacks to women who are on Valium because they're having such a rotten time in real life," she said. "They don't want to read about the kitchen sink, they can look at that any time they're peeling potatoes. I'm their escape. I give them glamour, beautiful clothes, and the marvellous attentive men they are starving for." 

Not every reader was an exhausted housewife: one photograph captured a teenage Diana Spencer reading a Cartland book. The future princess was more than just a fan, though. Barbara's daughter Raine married Diana's father, Earl Spencer, in 1976, making the writer her step-grandmother. 

'A life full of contradictions' 

The peak of Cartland's success coincided with the rise of second-wave feminism – a movement Cartland disapproved of. The feeling was mutual. In The Female Eunuch, Germaine Greer said Cartland's work was "sterile self-deception".

Sweet argues Cartland's books offered a counterpoint to the social shifts of the time. "When we think of the 1960s we think of this permissive society, but an awful lot of people didn't like that kind of thing," he says. "She was representing those swathes of women who never signed up for feminism in the '60s or '70s and wanted something else. As a historian, you can't dismiss that."

Getty Images Cartland's memorable persona featured a small dog under her arm (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Burge agrees that some women might have found the changes in society overwhelming, and sought comfort in the familiarity of Cartland's worlds – but she also thinks we shouldn't assume her readers craved what was depicted in her books. "Because of their historical setting, her books offered a safe space to play with ideas about submissiveness and dominant masculinity that women didn't necessarily want in their real lives," she says.

More like this:

Cartland's own life was full of contradictions. A social climber who loved nothing more than mingling with aristocracy and royalty, she spent her political career – a decade as a Conservative county councillor – championing the causes of those she thought hard done by, from underpaid nurses to neglected care home residents. 

One of her more surprising chapters was when she became a fierce campaigner for the rights of the Romany Gypsy community. Her activism led to the creation of Britain's first permanent Gypsy site – nicknamed Barbaraville.

Getty Images Cartland spent her life championing the causes of those she thought hard done by, from underpaid nurses to neglected care home residents (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

And while Cartland might have dismissed the feminist movement, she also once argued that women should be paid by the state for domestic labour. "I think this is why she's so interesting because she's impossible to classify," says Sweet.

In 1960, Cartland co-founded the Romantic Novelists Association, an organisation that's still going strong. Romance as a literary genre is currently surging in popularity, especially with young readers, but although Cartland sold 750 million books you'll struggle to find a copy in a bookshop today. 

"They are written for their moment, I think, and they express the desires and wants of a readership who don't exist anymore," says Sweet.

Burge says although Cartland's writing is no longer widely read, she's still seen as a hugely important figure in the world of romantic fiction – not least for bringing more attention to the genre. "She had a very strong sense of brand. I think a large part of her legacy is that of the blockbuster author." 

Cartland once said that "women shouldn't have character… they should be like pretty chocolate boxes" – but she was, and remains, a bigger persona than anyone. "She has this irresistible main character energy that means it's been a total pleasure to write about her," says Sweet. "She never did anything by halves."

The Great Dictator by Matthew Sweet is published on 10 September. 

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260910-five-things-you-need-to-know-about-the-new-four-hour-elon-musk-documentary?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[Five things about the new Elon Musk documentary]]> Thu, 10 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

Five things you need to know about the new four-hour Elon Musk documentary

Venice Film Festival A still of Elon Musk from the documentary Musk, with an American flag behind his head (Credit: Venice Film Festival)Venice Film Festival

The Venice Film Festival has hosted the premiere of major documentary-maker Alex Gibney's epic and provocative new profile of the richest man on Earth, which has been years in the making. Here are five key takeaways from the film.

Alex Gibney, the Oscar-winning director of Taxi to the Dark Side and Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, has made documentaries about some of the richest and most powerful people on Earth. But none of them has been as rich and powerful as Elon Musk. Maybe that's why Gibney's profile of the tech entrepreneur and SpaceX boss is such an epic. Musk, which premiered at the Venice Film Festival on Tuesday, has a running time of 225 minutes, and will be released with a 10-minute intermission – so that's almost four hours on the life and work of the world's richest man.

Still, the time rockets by. There is little in the film that isn't already on record, but Gibney gathers all the extant reporting into one breathlessly fast-moving, largely negative, and terrifyingly apocalyptic profile. Here are five things you should know about the documentary – just in case you don't have four hours to spare.

1. Musk himself isn't interviewed – but appears as an AI avatar

Gibney initially tried for an interview with Musk, but when the project was announced back in March 2023, Musk declared on social media that it would be a "hit piece", to which Gibney responded, "How would you know?" The director's solution is to have an AI-generated avatar of Musk repeat things that he has said in public. This is apt, says Gibney in his voiceover, because Musk believes that we might all be living in a simulation – a video game being played by our descendants in the future.

Getty Images Legendary musician David Byrne is one of the film's surprise contributors (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

2. David Byrne helped write a theme song

David Byrne has co-written Let Me Sell You a Dream for the film's closing credits, which has lyrics consisting entirely of phrases spoken by Musk in the past. The title is appropriate, according to some of Gibney's interviewees, who say that Musk tends to attract investment by promising that imagined future accomplishments – such as cities on Mars and completely safe self-driving cars – are imminent or already realised. "That's not happening," says Adam Becker, an author and astrophysicist, about Musk's scheme to colonise Mars. "The gravity is too low, the radiation is too high, there's no air, and the dirt is filled with poison." Musk has consistently defended his visionary philosophy however: "I'm very good at predicting the future," he told The Economist in a July interview. "I'm not perfect but I'm very good… people don't realise that what I'm saying will come to pass – maybe not exactly in the timing that I thought, but it will come to pass."

Getty Images Musk's time as head of the US Department of Government Efficiency is one of the many aspects of his life and career explored (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

3. Musk's time in the White House is scrutinised  

The film suggests that Musk dealt with the US government the way he dealt with Twitter. Zoë Schiffer, the author of Extremely Hardcore: Inside Elon Musk's Twitter, says that after Musk bought the social media platform, what she refers to as his "goons" pushed out the majority of the staff without pausing to learn what they actually did. Later, as the head of President Trump's Department of Government Efficiency, or Doge, Musk followed "the Twitter playbook", Schiffer says, describing how he tried and failed to wipe out the US national debt by slashing the budget of numerous departments, this time with the help of a group of assistants in their early twenties who had no government experience. Musk bemoaned that Doge had become "the whipping boy for everything" in an interview with the Washington Post in May last year, just before leaving the Trump administration.

Getty Images Excerpts from 1930s British fantasy film The Man Who Could Work Miracles feature (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

4. An old British film makes a surprise appearance

Gibney uses clips from a British fantasy film, The Man Who Could Work Miracles (1937), to illustrate his very dramatic view of Musk. In this black-and-white classic, based on an HG Wells story, a celestial being bestows an ordinary man (Roland Young) with infinite powers. The man eventually demands that the world's leaders change society instantly, but he ends up accidentally destroying the planet.

Alamy Alex Gibney promoting the film in Venice with author Zoë Schiffer and Musk's ex-girlfriend Ashley St Clair, who both feature (Credit: Alamy)Alamy

5. The film has had a strong reception so far

Reviews from the Venice premiere have so far been largely positive. Variety called it "a lacerating and important watch, grounded in Gibney's supremely insightful but user-friendly mastery of the documentary form", while in a four-star review, The Telegraph dubbed it "a chillingly forensic hatchet job". Unsurprisingly, Musk himself has not been one of its admirers: on X on Wednesday, among other comments, he described the film as "a hit piece that misses, and makes the fatal sin of being boring for 4 hours".

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260909-how-the-obscenity-trial-against-1950s-poem-howl-reshaped-us-free-speech?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[How 'obscene' poem Howl reshaped US free speech]]> Wed, 09 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'Revolutionary in form and content': How the obscenity trial against 1950s poem Howl reshaped US free speech

Getty Images Black and white image of Allan Ginsberg, reading sheets of paper with his other fist raised, sat alongside fellow Beat poets (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Allan Ginsberg's graphic verse had a seismic effect on American society. When two people were put on trial for selling it, the judgement was a landmark moment in loosening censorship.

On 7 October 1955, Allen Ginsberg first performed his poem Howl, destined to be a defining work of the Beat Generation – a bohemian, nonconformist literary subculture rejecting the US's post-World War Two social order.

Only a select few gathered at the Six Gallery in San Francisco. Yet less than two years later, Ginsberg and Howl would be infamous. In 1957, both were at the centre of a high-profile obscenity trial that would change the course of literary censorship for decades, and help to liberalise 1950s Cold War America.

Ginsberg's book Howl and Other Poems – the classic 1959 live performance album of which is newly reissued on vinyl this month – saw few sales when first put on the shelves of City Lights Books in San Francisco in 1956. But, with the trial, the content of the 112-stanza poem went on to cause national outrage. Religious groups and conservative authorities were shocked by its profanity and graphic depictions of drug-taking, homosexuality and mental illness.

Getty Images Ginsberg reading his work in New York's Washington Square Park in the 1960s – with Howl he became a counterculture icon (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

"[Its publication] was near the height of Cold War culture," says Jonah Raskin, author of American Scream: Allen Ginsberg's Howl and the Making of the Beat Generation. "A time of censorship of news and information, of intense conformity, of repression of people for their political beliefs and for being homosexual."   

Printed in England for cost-effectiveness, Howl was imported into the US for sale. The first shipment arrived without issue, but in March 1957, 520 copies from the UK were seized by US customs for being obscene: one inspector told reporters "you wouldn't want your children coming across it". Then when in June, two undercover police bought a copy of the book from City Lights, both owner Lawrence Ferlinghetti and bookshop manager Shig Murao were arrested and charged with selling obscene material.

It has this infectious defiance embedded. It's revolutionary in form and very, very revolutionary in content – Jonah Raskin

The trial became national news, with the eventual ruling in favour of Ferlinghetti and Murao paving the way for generations of artistic autonomy. Judge Clayton Horn declared the poem was not obscene, asserting in his key finding that Howl had "redeeming social importance". "It was absolutely a landmark case in free speech and against censorship and freedom of expression," says Raskin. 

The US's first literary obscenity trial dated back to 1821, when John Cleland's 1779 novel Fanny Hill: Memoirs of a Woman of Pleasure, about the life of a sex worker, was banned. Since the 19th Century, US obscenity law had been modelled on that in Britain, which itself was founded on the 1868 Regina v Hicklin case, centred on an anti-Catholic pamphlet. The Hicklin Test decreed "the test of obscenity is whether the tendency… is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences". Oscar Wilde, Ernest Hemingway, Henry Miller and DH Lawrence all had books in part or fully banned in the US as a result.

"Literary censorship was alive and well in the 1950s," says Ira Wells, author of On Book Banning. "In fact, state and municipal censorship boards were mostly expanding their censorship capacities. While censors were particularly preoccupied with sensationalistic dime novels, they also went after sexual, and particularly homosexual, material." 

The genesis of Howl

Ginsberg, the son of a socialist father and a mother who joined the Communist Party, began writing what became Howl on 8 June, 1955 after he awoke from a dream conversation with his friend Joan Vollmer. She was an early beat writer who died in 1951 after being shot by her partner William S Burroughs during a disputed drunken incident in Mexico. In the dream, Ginsberg wrote in his journal, Vollmer asked about their Beat Generation friends. "These people had their mental health struggles," says David S Wills, author and editor of the journal Beatdom. "And he was very determined to celebrate them, to record their lives."

Getty Images Defence lawyer Jake Ehrlich standing with defendants Lawrence Ferlinghetti and Shigeyoshi Murao during the Howl obscenity trial (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

As the poem initially titled by Ginsberg Dream Record: June 8, 1955 evolved into the epic three-part Howl, he portrayed mental illness as both a personal tragedy and a societal issue.

Ginsberg had spent eight months in New York State Psychiatric Institute during 1949 and 1950 as part of a plea deal after being convicted of handling stolen goods, while his mother and long-term partner Peter Orlovsky also struggled with severe mental health issues. His experiences with his and others' mental illness are captured in Howl's arresting opening line: "I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked." Ginsberg wrote Part 2 during a terrifying psychedelic trip, during which he hallucinated the Francis Drake building in San Francisco became monstrous.

Otherwise, Howl was a darkly humorous, scathing critique of oppressive 1950s US conservative orthodoxies. It rejected social conformity and railed against "Moloch" – a reference to the corrupting God in the Hebrew Bible that was Ginsberg's hallucinated catch-all emblem for what he saw as the US's dehumanising ills, namely capitalism, government tyranny and the military industrial complex.

Howl promoted free thinking, substance experimentation and explicit gay sexual freedom with evocative language and surrealist imagery. When performed, its erratic jazz-like rhythms also became apparent. "It has this infectious defiance embedded," Raskin says. "It's revolutionary in form and very, very revolutionary in content."

How the trial played out 

By the time Ferlinghetti and Murao's trial began on 16 August 1957, there had been a softening of the obscenity law that worked in theirs and Ginsberg's favour. "There were glimmers of change," Wells says. Weeks prior, Roth v United States created a new standard that stated literature was protected by the right to free speech as in the First Amendment. 

Still the prosecution, led by Ralph McIntosh, argued Howl was devoid of social value, promoted juvenile delinquency and that Ferlinghetti and Murao acted with lewd intent. The defence was led by American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), with lead attorney, famous criminal lawyer Jake Ehrlich, calling nine prominent scholars, critics and professors to argue its artistic merit. Ginsberg was in Europe and South Africa during the trial, though wrote supportive letters to Ferlinghetti.

Getty Images A sketch of Ginsberg taking to the stand as a defence witness during 1969's 'Chicago Seven' trial, when he read sections of Howl (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

Horn's ruling on 3 October was a demand that words used in literature should be contextualised, and judgement of a work's obscenity had to take into account the publication as a whole. It further asked: "Would there be any freedom of press or speech if one must reduce his vocabulary to vapid euphemism?"

The impact of the judgement

The cultural consequences of the judgement were seismic. For Ginsberg, the verdict meant not only validation, but notoriety and success: Howl and Other Poems went on to sell one million copies. It encouraged his convictions and emboldened his work. 1973's The Fall of America: Poems of These States featured sexually explicit anti-war and anti-authority material. Ginsberg's fellow Beat writers, such as Burroughs and Jack Kerouac, also became famous and promoted a message of radical personal liberty, sexual openness and spiritual awakening. "If Howl hadn't had such a sensational trial, it wouldn't have generated the sort of cultural force to make the Beat Generation an international thing," Wills says. 

Of even greater significance, the precedent set by Judge Horn led to a far-reaching, liberal interpretation of free speech. "It's the turning point when everything changes," Wills says. Over the next few years, previously banned books in the US – from Lady Chatterley's Lover to Tropic of Cancer – all won trials to overturn their bans. Publishers became bolder: Gove Press published Burroughs' controversial novel Naked Lunch in 1962. "We start getting much more opening up to anything that has literary merit," Wills says. "Would that have been possible without Howl? I don't think so." 

Hollywood was also buoyed by the Howl judgement. Film-makers could now use the "redeeming social importance" legal standard to bypass the Motion Picture Association's strict Hays Code and tackle previously forbidden subjects.

More like this:

The new-found countercultural attitude that Howl and the result of the obscenity trial helped foster spread across the US and beyond. "It all rapidly happened in 1957," Wills says. "And then by 1958, it became a national obsession. Over the next three years there was the beat/beatnik/hipster/bohemian obsession across the country. Then that turned into the hippie movement. It was this snowball effect."

A line can certainly be drawn from Howl to the social revolutions of the 1960s. "The '60s generation who were protesting against the Vietnam war and segregation were the sons and daughters of Howl," Raskin says. Ginsberg himself was seen as the figurehead of the decade's counterculture, inspiring Bob Dylan and being a vociferous anti-war voice. 

When the so-called "Chicago Seven" went on trial in 1969 for Vietnam War protests, Ginsberg was called as a defence witness due to his prominent role in organising the protests, to explain their movement's peaceful, spiritual intentions. During his testimony, he passionately read sections of Howl during cross-examination. "More than a decade after it was first published, it still had renewed life and vibrancy," Raskin says.

Yet history suggests arguments over literary censorship are never truly settled. Recent years have seen an increase in banned books in schools and libraries in the US, with the American Library Association recording a record 5,668 instances of book-banning from libraries in 2025.

"Some [people] are still convinced that words can function as a contagion," Wells believes. "Judge Horn found that artists needed the freedom to use words to explore and express their interior selves. Whether we will continue to have the right to read those expressions remains an open question."

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week. 

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260907-10-stunning-buildings-blended-with-nature?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[10 stunning buildings 'blended' with nature]]> Tue, 08 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

A Mexican forest haven to a Florida dream home: 10 stunning buildings 'blended' with nature

Andrés Cedillo A green building nestled among trees (Credit: Andrés Cedillo)Andrés Cedillo

Here are some of the world's best new buildings that are immersed in their wild surroundings.

The impulse to be immersed in nature at its most wild and untouched is a powerful one for many of us. It goes hand in hand with the human longing for tranquility, and the urge to escape the city and the modern world, along with pressing concerns about the environment.

And buildings that blend with their natural surroundings are increasingly sought after, according to the World Architecture Festival (WAF). Architects are allowing their imaginations to run free, and are exploring new, expressive ideas – from dwellings immersed in the jungle or with roofs open to the skies, to residences seemingly cradled, nest-like, among the trees.

The annual festival – taking place in Florida this year – is spotlighting many nature-inspired projects, as its shortlist demonstrates. "There's an increased interest in incorporating nature into buildings in terms of external landscape, and via balconies, terraces and rooftops," Paul Finch, WAF's founder, tells the BBC. "And there's an assumption that good buildings will be environmentally considered rather than this being exceptional."

Here are 10 projects from the shortlist, all deeply rooted in nature. 

Ishita Sitwala (Credit: Ishita Sitwala)Ishita Sitwala

Ayana resort in Sholayur, Coimbatore, India

This 40,000-sq ft resort occupies a sloped terrain, and one of its aims is to minimise its impact on the landscape. The complex, designed by Aslam Sham Architects, comprises closely grouped buildings, and fills a plot with a curving perimeter. Its buildings include villas, a restaurant and swimming pool, and their roofs support soil and indigenous vegetation. These help to camouflage the resort. The complex's orientation controls the degree of sunlight it's exposed to. The main, east-facing façade is bathed in gentle sunlight in the mornings, while the west-facing rear protects the complex from harsh sunlight and greatly cools its interior.

PHX INDIA (Credit: PHX INDIA)PHX INDIA

Terra House in Mallapuram, Kerala, India

The low-rise, horizontal form of this house by Atelier Design N Domain (ADND) complements the flat terrain of the surrounding, sprawling coconut grove. As its name suggests, it's grounded in the landscape ("terra" means land in Latin). The unobtrusive house is concealed by towering coconut trees but isn't cut off from the sky since its roof is punctured with openings, letting daylight flood in. Light and air further permeate the interior thanks to a series of interconnected courtyards. Materials typically used in construction in Kerala help link the house with its location. A locally quarried stone called laterite clads the exterior while other surfaces are rendered with terracotta, adding warmth.

Arch-Exist Photography (Credit: Arch-Exist Photography)Arch-Exist Photography

The Mountain Fold – Nanshanli Community and Visitor Centre, near Mount Emei, China

This project by Lacime Architects nestles in the southern foothills of Mount Emei in the inland Sichuan province – a Unesco World Cultural and Natural Heritage site. The mountain has a spiritual significance as one of China's four sacred Buddhist mountains. The centre borders the scenic Guanshan Lake, and is part of a private wellness resort but also open to the public. It incorporates a reception, rooms for community activities, wellness facilities and a dining area. The roof's complex geometry references different elements of the landscape. It undulates above arches, echoing the foothills' rounded silhouettes, while its angular spike nods to the mountain's peak. And the roof's gleaming, gunmetal grey cladding mirrors the silvery sheen of the lake's surface.

Jeanne Canto (Credit: Jeanne Canto)Jeanne Canto

Kiaora Residence, Coconut Grove, Miami, US

This two-storey family home designed by Strang is in a leafy, subtropical Miami suburb and comprises two interlocking, rectangular structures. These connect to a large garden with swimming pools, helping to dissolve the boundary between indoors and out, an effect enhanced by trailing plants cascading over windows. An upper-level comprises shared living spaces, and the lower one private rooms. An abundance of wooden screens with decorative diagonal openings allows cool air to circulate inside.

Paul Warchol (Credit: Paul Warchol)Paul Warchol

Chatham Residence guest house in Columbia County, New York, US

This house by Desai Chia Architecture stands on raised ground on land also used for farming. From its elevated position, it has views of the Catskill Mountains and of heavily wooded countryside – expansive windows at the front and back reveal a vista of the mountains. The upper part of the façade is clad in corrugated metal, partly chosen as the material is frequently used in contemporary farm buildings.

Fernando Guerra (Credit: Fernando Guerra)Fernando Guerra

ES House in Guarujá, São Paulo, Brazil 

Jacobsen Studio's clients hankered after a home that blended into the surrounding forest landscape. The building appears to hover against its backdrop of dense, lush vegetation. The house is largely supported by a tree-shaped structure, reducing its contact with the ground. It's mainly hidden from view, accessed from a street behind it, and is entered via the roof that doubles as a garden. 

 

Avesh Gaur and Sohaib Ilyas (Credit: Avesh Gaur and Sohaib Ilyas)Avesh Gaur and Sohaib Ilyas

The Hungry Caterpillar pavilion at Ashoka University, Delhi, India

This is an urban project but, aesthetically, decidedly organic. The architects Lyth Design's brief was to design a street with character, where students would want to spend time beyond hurriedly grabbing a meal. Food is served from modular units dotting the street. Writhing, soaring, tornado-like structures, made of highly sustainable bamboo – playfully likened to a ravenous caterpillar – provide much-needed shade when temperatures hit 38C (100F), as well as protection during the summer monsoon. 

Andrés Cedillo (Credit: Andrés Cedillo)Andrés Cedillo

Mercado Nicolás Bravo in Quintana Roo, Mexico

This crafts market is a government-funded project used by the local community to sell artisanal goods and fresh produce to visitors exploring nearby Mayan archaeological sites. Located in the municipality of Nicolas Bravo in the state of Quintana Roo, the project by Aidia Studio doubles as a community centre. It comprises three key elements – a lightweight steel structure, pigmented concrete block walls and clay bricks cladding the roof and paving. Its gracefully vaulted roof collects water used for irrigation, and the building enjoys unobstructed views of the adjoining countryside.

Andrés Cedillo (Credit: Andrés Cedillo)Andrés Cedillo

Parque Quintana Roo in Chetumal, Mexico

This park is another a government-funded initiative by Aida Studio – in this case a venue hosting an annual livestock and agricultural fair. It's now also a venue for concerts and features amusement rides and craft markets. The 10-hectare fairground is enveloped by subtropical jungle. Slender, olive-green columns and undulating wooden elements were chosen to help integrate the park with the surrounding subtropical forest.

Studio CAPN (Credit: Studio CAPN)Studio CAPN

Stöng (Re)interpretation shelter in Stöng í Þjórsárdal, Iceland

This project by Sp(r)int Studio performs a dual function. It conserves the ruins of an 11th-Century Viking-era farm which was buried and preserved under volcanic ash – one of Iceland's most valued archaeological sites – and extends the site thanks to the creation of a larger shelter made of untreated larchwood, galvanised steel and recyclable polycarbonate. An original timber frame in poor condition that once protected the ruins was retained, reinforced and used as the project's core structure. The shelter now offers new amenities, including a sitting area and platforms for viewing the ruins, raised from the ground to avoid disturbing the terrain.

--

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can't-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram.

]]>
BBC Culture
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20260904-the-poison-tipped-umbrella-that-pointed-to-a-kgb-murder?ocid=global_culture_rss <![CDATA[The poisoned umbrella that pointed to a KGB murder]]> Mon, 07 Sep 2026 11:00:00 +0000

'Eliminate him without trace': The poison-tipped umbrella that pointed to a KGB murder - on British soil

Getty Images A black and white close up portrait of Georgi Markov (Credit: Getty Images)Getty Images

In London, 7 September 1978, Georgi Markov was killed with an umbrella, in what is suspected to have been a political poisoning by the KGB. He died four days later. The following year, Markov's widow and elder brother told the BBC's Panorama that they were warned about the murder plot just months before – by an anonymous man.

"He'd felt a jab in his thigh. And he'd looked round, and there'd been a man behind him who'd apologised and dropped an umbrella." These are the words of Annabel Markov, talking about her husband Georgi Markov, a Bulgarian dissident, journalist and writer.

On 7 September 1978, 49-year-old Markov was waiting at a bus stop on Waterloo Bridge in central London when he said he'd been stabbed with an umbrella. Four days later he died in hospital, with doctors initially diagnosing blood poisoning. Yet detectives soon realised it had been a political murder, one that had used a highly sophisticated technique that also targeted another Bulgarian exile.

Markov's widow and elder brother told the BBC's Panorama in 1979 how an anonymous man warned them that Markov was going to be poisoned, months before his death.

And interviews with the former head of a KGB assassination squad and a former colonel in the Bulgarian secret service, both then talking publicly for the first time, placed the assassination at the highest levels of the Bulgarian and Soviet governments.

In the days following Markov's death, Britain's anti-terrorist squad found a clue that convinced them that he had been the victim of a unique murder plot. "At Scotland Yard's forensic laboratory, the chief scientific officer examined a minute metal object that had been found in Markov's thigh," said Panorama reporter Michael Cockerell.

"Under the microscope, it was clear that the object was an extraordinarily sophisticated pellet, no bigger than a pinhead. It had four tiny holes passing through that the forensic experts were convinced had contained an infinitesimally tiny amount of a lethally toxic poison."

The decision had been taken at the highest political level in Bulgaria to kill him

Scientists at Porton Down, the top-secret British chemical and microbiological warfare research establishment, believed that what had killed Markov was the highly lethal toxin ricin. According to Panorama, it had never before been used for murder in Britain.

It emerged that another Bulgarian exile might have been attacked in a similar way 10 days before Markov was stabbed. Vladimir Kostov had felt a sharp pain in his back as he was leaving the Paris Metro with his wife. He had a high fever for three days but recovered.

After hearing of Markov's death, Kostov had his back X-rayed, which revealed a tiny metal object. At a clinic in Paris, a surgeon operated on him under the eye of a French police officer wearing a surgical mask and gown. 

"The surgeon had to be extremely careful. He removed the metal pellet without touching it at all," Kostov told the BBC. It was then given to a Scotland Yard inspector and taken to England for analysis.

Using a high-powered scanning electron microscope, Scotland Yard metallurgists analysed the pellet removed from Kostov's back, finding that it was identical to the one found in Markov. "Both pellets weighed exactly the same," said Cockerell. "The holes were in the same places, and both were made of a rare platinum iridium alloy that the human body does not reject."

A man phoned me saying the decision has been taken to kill Georgi, to eliminate him without trace – Annabel Markov

Toxicologists at Porton Down found ricin antibodies in Kostov's flesh and concluded he'd survived because there hadn't been enough poison in the pellet.

The sophisticated technique used – and evidence of coordinated attacks – convinced Scotland Yard that a state secret service organisation had played a role in Markov's death.

A novelist and playwright previously acclaimed in his native country, moving within the government elite there, Markov had defected from then-communist Bulgaria in 1969. After settling in the UK, he'd become an outspoken opponent of the Bulgarian government, working for the BBC's World Service as well as Radio Free Europe (RFE), a US state-funded media organisation.

Annabel Markov said that they had received warnings of a plot to kill her husband, telling the BBC that a man had contacted Georgi in May 1978. 

"They spoke Bulgarian all evening. Every so often Georgi would turn to me and say in English, 'this is extraordinary what this man's saying'." According to Annabel, the anonymous man said that the decision had been taken at the highest political level in Bulgaria to kill him, because of the outspoken broadcasts Georgi was writing for RFE.

Markov's brother Nikola backed this up, revealing that he had received a call in September 1977. "A man phoned me saying the decision has been taken to kill Georgi, to eliminate him without trace," he told the BBC.

"At first, I didn't believe it. It seemed absurd, impossible. But the man gave me quite specific details about which there could be no doubt. He told me Georgi would definitely be poisoned at the first opportunity… that a sort of poison or some sort of bacteria, he didn't know exactly which, had already been brought out to Western Europe."

'An outspoken opponent'

After moving to the UK, Markov remained a celebrity at home through his talks on RFE, broadcasting weekly programmes about what life was really like at the upper echelons of Bulgarian society. One of his broadcasts was called Life Behind the Curtains, referring to the little curtains on the side and back of every official black Mercedes. He presented a gossipy but damning picture of the misuse of absolute power in the country, with stories about nepotism, financial abuse and corruption.

While the Bulgarian government officially denied that Markov's broadcasts had any influence, the BBC found that the Bulgarian president, Todor Zhivkov, took particularly strong exception to a revealing series of Markov's talks called My Meetings with Todor Zhivkov.

"We have heard that he was quite furious about Markov's talks concerning the meetings with him," said a Bulgarian broadcaster for RFE, Kyril Panov. "[Markov] was talking about things which are, so to speak, taboo in Bulgaria, things which the regime prefers not to talk about and that the public should not know."

In History

In History is a series which uses the BBC's unique audio and video archive to explore historical events that still resonate today. Sign up to the accompanying weekly newsletter. 

Zhivkov had ruled Bulgaria since 1956 – and had very close ties to the Soviet Union, describing the relationship between the two countries as like two lungs in the same body, fed by the same bloodstream.

Experts believed that the Soviets must have been involved in Markov's murder. 

Stefan Sverdlov, a colonel in the Bulgarian secret police until he defected in 1971, told the BBC in 1979: "Every department of the Darzhavna Sigurnost [Bulgarian secret service] is controlled by an advisor from the Russian KGB, sometimes known as an uncle, who reports directly to Moscow… It's inconceivable that this could have been done without the Russians knowing about it."

And according to the former head of an assassination squad for the KGB, the method pointed to Soviet involvement. "The technique is… almost ridiculously sophisticated," said Nikolai Khokhlov. "That tells me that the officers who were planning that operation tried to please someone on the highest level." The fatal attack on Markov was carried out on Zhivkov's birthday.

After the fall of the Soviet Union, it emerged that the KGB had developed an umbrella that could inject ricin pellets into a victim. And two former KGB officers who defected later said their organisation assisted in the murder, although it was carried out by an Italian criminal codenamed Piccadilly. 

No one has ever been charged for Markov's assassination. Bulgaria closed the case in 2013, due to a lack of suspects, but it remains an open inquiry in the UK. 

More like this:

It would have benefited the Soviets in more than one way, as former KGB officer Khokhlov told the BBC in 1979 – beyond the physical death, it would have had a great psychological impact on dissenters abroad. "The fear that they're not protected by distance, they're not protected by the security systems of the West", he said.

He continued: "The action is like coming behind someone and whispering in his ear, 'We can get you any time we want. We can kill you.'" 

--

For more stories and never-before-published radio scripts to your inbox, sign up to the In History newsletter, while The Essential List delivers a handpicked selection of features and insights twice a week.  

For more Culture stories from the BBC, follow us on Facebook and Instagram. 

]]>
BBC Culture